Staten Island's History of Working Class Fight Back
Plea for the Fifth led a walking tour on the North Shore's rich history of working people fighting back.

Plea for the Fifth led a walking tour on Saturday, November 14 on working people from our community fighting for better workplaces, against war or racism, for safer streets, and much more.
A summary of our tour is reproduced, in brief, below.
219 Canal Street
Participants visited 219 Canal Street, formerly the Paramount Grill, where workers at the bar struck on September 10, 1954 to improve their working conditions.

355 Front Street
The current location of Urby was, until 1994, Naval Station New York - the homeport of the U.S.S. Iowa battleship. During the 1980s, activist groups like Coalition for a Nuclear Free Harbor and the Committee for a Nuclear Free Island were opposed to hosting ships capable of hosting nuclear weapons in a densely populated urban harbor. Their actions included:
- A 1984 petition drive gathered 30,000 signatures against the base.
- A 1985 rally with performances by Pete Seeger and Richie Havens, and a "human chain" across the Verrazano Bridge.
- A 1987 trespassing protest at the site
Their central argument was that a nuclear accident or attack on the warships could have devastating consequences for millions of people in the surrounding area.


Dramatic messaging in opposition to navy ships being based on Staten Island. (PJ Mode Collection at Cornell’s Digital Library; Coalition for a Nuclear Free Harbor)
207 St Pauls Avenue
This neo-colonial-style house at 207 St. Paul’s Avenue on Staten Island was designed by Otto Loeffler in 1898. From 1972 to 1987, the house was the primary residence of renowned African-American and lesbian writer Audre Lorde. Lorde wrote many of her most famous books and poems during the time she occupied this house. In 1973, her third volume of poetry, From a Land Where Other People Live, was nominated for a National Book Award, and over the next several years she published important poetry collections, essays, and novels, including Coal (1976), The Black Unicorn (1978), The Cancer Journals (1980), and Zami: A New Spelling of My Name (1982).
Lorde's most enduring legacy is her powerful theories on identity and social justice. Her writing centered on the idea that oppressions are interconnected and cannot be fought in isolation.

200 Bay Street
On July 17, 2014, Eric Garner, a 43-year-old unarmed Black man and father of six, was approached by plainclothes NYPD officers on Staten Island. They suspected him of illegally selling untaxed "loose" cigarettes. According to police, Garner resisted arrest, but a bystander's video captured the confrontation that followed.
The video shows Officer Daniel Pantaleo placing Garner in what appeared to be a chokehold, a technique that has been banned by the NYPD since 1993. Garner was wrestled to the ground, and he can be heard repeatedly gasping, "I can't breathe," at least 11 times. He eventually lost consciousness on the sidewalk. An ambulance arrived approximately seven minutes after he lost consciousness, and no CPR was administered at the scene. Garner was later pronounced dead at a hospital.
Garner's murder contributed to the movement for black lives on Staten Island, and nationwide.

55 Richmond Terrace
Empire Outlets, New York City's first outlet mall, is a story of a $350 million project that opened with great fanfare. Development no community member called for, but was imposed, has been a complete failure.
221 Richmond Terrace
The New York Wheel was a massive, $900 million failed project on Staten Island's North Shore meant to create a world-class tourist attraction, but it was ultimately undone by soaring costs, legal battles, and a lack of public funding support .
Announced in 2012 by Mayor Michael Bloomberg, the centerpiece was to be a 630-foot (190-meter) observation wheel, taller than the London Eye. All that was ultimately built was a parking structure that would have served as the wheel’s base.
NYCEDC announced in November 2025 a vision plan for the North Shore, including redevelopment at 55 & 221 Richmond Terrace. Three Towers are planned for Empire Outlets a 22-story, 25-story and 30-story residential buildings. At NY Wheel there are currently proposals to build as many three towers, a 17-story, 22-story and 30-story residential buildings.
Groups like Take Back St. George are organizing to have a community led alternative to include necessities like a supermarket or community center.




Recently proposed development for the North Shore. (NYCEDC)